The call came in at 9:47pm, and Sheriff Monohan grunted in boredom as the dispatcher relayed the details. When the dispatcher spoke the word “murder” the Sheriff grunted again, this time in interest. It had been three years, two months, and four days since the last murder in Brushy Creek. Things were rarely that interesting around here. Sheriff Monohan drawled his response into his handheld radio as we walked briskly out to his car. As briskly as he could, anyway. He had put on a little weight in the last three years, two months, and four days.
He pulled his vehicle up to the house slowly, without his lights on. He had found that it helped him to understand any crime scene if he could observe it and gather his own opinions before being bombarded with the opinions of eager but inexperienced subordinates. He stopped the car short of the fence that marked the property line and got out to walk along the fence.
He saw that all of the activity outside the house was clustered in two areas. Deputy Willis was in the back yard with a flashlight, performing what he probably though was a methodical and thorough search for something. Probably the murder weapon. Sheriff Monohan watch the bobbing of the flashlight and shook his head. Willis would have been better off keeping guard on the lot until daylight and searching it then.
At the front of the house, Deputy Thompson had just joined Deputy Abrams with the family that lived here. The Sheriff searched his mind for just a minute before coming up with the name Samson. The Samson family had moved here about a year ago, he remembered, and had raised quite a stir with their moron son. That was him there, sitting on the steps.
He could see the wife and the daughter, but the husband and the other son were nowhere to be seen. Which one had been killed, or had it been a guest or stranger? No, for both of them to be missing it almost seemed like the son had killed his father and then run for it. Maybe. But then why hadn’t Thompson or Abrams started a search yet? It was time to officially arrive on the scene and get the details.
As he stepped out from around the side of the house, Deputy Thompson said, “There you are, Leo! I saw your car, but Abrams here said she hadn’t seen you. How do you do that?” Sheriff Leo Monohan ignored him and turned to Abrams, obviously the first person on the scene.
In response to his question, Deputy Abrams gave him the details. The older son had been away for three weeks and wasn’t expected back for another week. They hadn’t been able to reach him by phone. Mr. Samson was dead, shot with a revolver. The were powder marks on the dead man’s face and the side of his head, so he had obviously been shot at point blank range. There were also powder marks on the retarded boy’s hands. The gun had been found on the floor next to the dead man.
Now Sheriff Monohan noticed the handcuffs on the boy, and realized that the boy was rocking back and forth as he sat with his hands cuffed through the railing on the porch. He was moaning to himself and shaking his head.
At that point Mrs. Samson ran up to him and cried, “You must let my Jimmy go. He didn’t do it. Please, let him go! Can’t you see you’re hurting him?” As she talked, the boy on the porch rocked even more urgently and starting moaning even louder. The Sheriff held up his hand in what he hoped was an authoritative gesture. It silenced the woman, who had been on the verge of hysteria, but had no effect on the moaning of the boy.
The Sheriff addressed the woman quietly and as gently as he could. She responded by taking several deep breaths and stating that she believed her husband had committed suicide and that Jimmy had tried to stop him. “Jimmy could never have hurt anybody. He adored his father! Look at him, he’s going into shock. You’ve got to let him go! I know he didn’t do it. Please! Let him Go!” She was growing very upset again, very quickly.
Monohan turned away from her and glanced briefly at the daughter. She was standing near the porch, her eyes shifting back and forth from the retarded boy, Jimmy, to her mother. It seemed that she wasn’t quite convinced of Jimmy’s innocence, either. The Sheriff dismissed her for now as someone who didn’t have enough information. He turned back to Mrs. Samson and asked her why she felt her husband would commit suicide. She had no answer for that. The Sheriff gave a few instructions to his deputies and ambled out to his car to drive back to the station.
It was almost midnight when he got back to the station. Jimmy was sitting on a bench inside a jail cell, still rocking back and forth and moaning. Deputy Thompson was taking a statement from Mrs. Samson. He could hear her voice from behind two doors. Deputy Abrams was working on some paperwork and drinking what by now would be extremely stale coffee. The Sheriff lowered his bulky body into a chair near her and asked her for an update. They still hadn’t been able to reach the older son. The wife was still claiming it must have been suicide. The retarded son just kept moaning and bobbing.
The Sheriff was pondering the possibilities when he realized that Abrams was watching him quietly. She seemed to be expecting an answer to a question. As he focused on her, she realized that he hadn’t heard her and asked again, “So which one do you believe?” The daughter had been first to arrive on the scene, and she had seen the moron son come in through the back door. The mother knew more than she was telling, since she wouldn’t give any reason for her idea that her husband might have committed suicide. Could she just be trying to cut her losses? Would she be willing to demean her husband’s name to protect her son? The Sheriff had suggested the possibility of a self-defense plea to her and she had refused it, stating that her son would not even kill in self-defense.
It all hinged on this claim of suicide. What could have caused Mr. Samson to kill himself without leaving a note? Whatever it was, it had upset him so that he had made some noise. Perhaps he argued with his wife and then ran downstairs to get his gun, waking Jimmy in the process? The daughter’s bedroom was further down the hall from the stairs, so she could have missed the racket that caused Jimmy to go downstairs in time to try to stop his father. After the shot, the wife might have been frozen in shock for those few moments it took for the daughter to beat her downstairs and find the body first, as well as see Jimmy return from outside where he had disposed of… what? The gun was found next to Mr. Samson. Jimmy must have hidden whatever it was that upset Mr. Samson. Deputy Willis had found nothing but scattered trash and a few gardening utensils, certainly nothing that should prompt a hasty suicide.
The Sheriff realized that Deputy Abrams was still waiting for an answer. Instead of giving her one, he asked where Willis had left the trash from the back yard. She pointed him to a bag sitting on another desk. She looked as exhausted as he felt, so he told her to go home. Her eyes filled for a moment with indecision, as if her curiosity was battling with her fatigue. Finally, she glanced at the clock on the wall and sighed. As she was gathering her things to leave, the Sheriff started poking through the trash. Deputy Abrams had just started out the door when the Sheriff called her name. He was holding a page out of a newspaper.
It seemed that the older brother had been involved after all. Further rummaging through the garbage had turned up the envelope in which the newspaper clipping had arrived, complete with the older brother’s address and hand-written notes. Jimmy probably hadn’t understood what exactly was in the newspaper, but had been scared and upset about how it had disturbed his father. Sheriff Leo Monohan never showed anybody the clipping or the notes, just released Jimmy and sent him home with his mother and an apology.
The next day the coroner confirmed that the angle of the burn marks indicated a suicide, and a struggle consistent with the idea of Jimmy attempting to stop it. The coroner’s report was entered into the official file, but the Sheriff kept the clipping and the note locked into his personal office safe.